| Platinum | Apple Creek Arcade |
| Platinum | Old Town Pizza House Bar & Grill |
| Gold | Pauls Pizza Airdrie |
| Gold | The Vapiano Cucina Italian |
| Silver | Boston Pizza |
| Bronze | Johnny's Pizza & Wings |
| Top Pick | Alexander's Steakhouse & Pizzaria |
| Top Pick | Chicago Deep Dish Pizza |
| Top Pick | Ferraro Truly Italian |
| Top Pick | Red Swan Pizza |